I'd give these gloves a 5 if the liner was better. I used these up in the Baaken Oil Fields (brutally cold) and they stay reasonably warm and have great grip and protective features. Problem is once they liner gets sweat and wet sometimes the liner will pull out of the fingers and it's a real challenge to get everything back together again. For that reason alone I stopped wearing them and went to a Kinco 901 and never looked back. Those Kinco gloves are super warm and bulletproof.